We’re over and over again being told that trigeminal neuralgia is 'the
suicide disease' accompanied by some very disturbing statistics to “prove” it. Horrifying postulations are scaring sufferers, their family and friends. We have over months now gone digging deep. Is this information,
which is going viral, really true? Let’s make it perfectly clear right now: NO
IT IS NOT!
We want to emphasize, as you will see when you read on, that we know:
- how painful Trigeminal Neuralgia is
- that it's normal for people to sometimes feel they cannot cope with this horrendous pain (If you do have suicidal thoughts contact a helpline, your doctor or someone you can talk to immediately.)
- that the statistics which we keep seeing are totally false:
- Do statistics on suicide due to trigeminal neuralgia exist? NO. FALSE.
- Do 10, 26 or 50% commit suicide? NO. FALSE.
You don’t have to take our word for it, in the following we will show
you some of what we've found. We will show you how you’re being used. We will
show you why it can’t go on.
First we need to take a quick look back in history:
Where does the name come
from?
We do not know when the first person suffered from TN, but we do know
the first time the pain was mentioned in literature. It got recognized as an
illness as early as the 17th century with reports in literature as early as
2000 years ago.
It might have been a Professor of Medicine, Sir William Osler at Johns
Hopkins University (US), who first linked suicide and TN to the public
imagination. Osler was identifying the need for treatment and surgery, the
former mortality rate of patients (many due to brain tumors) and the frightful
intensity in which the attacks took place. Osler wrote about it repeatedly and
it’s included in his medical books from 1912.
Osler wrote about this more than 100 years ago. Osler was talking about
the past, the history of TN patients before his time and not as a scientific
fact. Osler has no mention of numbers or statistics in regards to suicide
and TN.
So, is it so painful?
There is no shortage of documentation that trigeminal neuralgia is one
of the most painful afflictions known to mankind. There is further no shortage
of documentation that literature and medical personnel call it the suicide
disease possibly due to the intensity of pain and that sufferers facing the
highest pain might contemplate that they can’t go on.
Does that mean I’m
suicidal?
No. Living with a
chronic affliction can be very tough on anyone regardless of situation, age,
finances etc. When the pain is horrendous, we are mentally and physically at
our worse and it is understandable to think “I can’t continue with this pain”.
When talking about suicide there is a difference between being passive
suicidal and suicidal. Let’s look at some definitions: Suicidal:
Purposeful self-injury with the intention to kill oneself (suicidal behavior),
or, verbalizing plan, intent, and having the means to complete a suicidal act. Passive
Suicidal Ideation (thoughts and statements): talking of thinking about
“being dead” or killing or hurting yourself, but not really doing it. For
example: “I wish I were dead. Sometimes I just want to kill myself, I feel so
depressed.”
It is not uncommon to feel this way and according to any government
information it is more common for women than for men to have these thoughts. Yes some have and some will choose to end their lives because of the pain. But
this does not mean that you are suicidal, on the brink of committing suicide or will
commit suicide because you have trigeminal neuralgia.
If you do have suicidal thoughts contact a helpline, your doctor or
someone you can talk to immediately.
To the disturbing
statistics that are being presented?
After reading thousands of pages, reports, searched extensively for more
than 6 months online, contacting organizations, support groups and reading
government statistics from various countries, we can with 99.9 % certainty say that there is no such
thing as any reliable statistics over people taking suicide because of having
trigeminal neuralgia. Statistics on suicide due to trigeminal neuralgia do not
exist. Anyone that claims to know statistics showing the number of
people that have committed suicide due to trigeminal neuralgia are either very
misinformed or actually lying.
Let’s take a closer look
"Trigeminal neuralgia is called the suicide disease. In fact, for
those who live with TN for more than 3 years, about half commit suicide." FALSE
In 2009 an article was published in a small journal around how to
resolve trigeminal neuralgia through the work of a chiropractor. While the rest
of the article is full of references, this rather disturbing statement
does NOT have any reference at all. Going though all the references provided we
did not find any mention of it either. When we also know that NO statistics
about trigeminal neuralgia and suicide exist we can say it is taken out of thin
air. The statement is false.
"The literature confirming the suicidal tendencies of someone
suffering through TN paroxysms is alarming. Approximately half of those people
who live with TN for more than three years commit suicide;" FALSE
This comes from an article published online by another author in late in
2011. The quote, half will commit suicide, is taken from the article from 2009.
It is interesting that a so called journalist comes with this kind of statement
without any background check. Further more citing from one source hardly merits
saying that the literature (as in plural) is confirming anything. If we are
kind we could say that the author might mean the passive suicidal ideation
(thoughts and statements) when we are in a bad place. Is this information
alarming then? No not at all, as we've written earlier (from many different
sources we might add) it is not uncommon at all to have such thought and it does
not mean that anyone actually will commit suicide. This statement is false.
So to 2 other postulates that have been around,
- 50% of
those having TN will commit suicide within two years
- Of the 1.7
million known sufferers of Trigeminal neuralgia 26% will commit suicide as
a result of the severe pain.
These we have not found anywhere else than in videos and on posters, but
we can speculate that they might have been inspired by the first article maybe,
being changed on the way to fit a dramatic message to bring about “awareness”
or maybe just made up.
But so that no one will
wonder "Can there be any truth in this?” NO there can not and there is not any truth in it. We'll have a
closer look at the actual numbers:
We can make it very easy: Every support group, organization etc working
with TN sufferers should see large numbers of deaths due to suicide every year.
After 1, 2, 3 or 5 years they see no such thing. Does every person having TN
lose half their friends in 2-3 years? No we don’t.
Actually most of us don’t
know anyone that has actually committed suicide due to trigeminal neuralgia, we
might have heard about 1 or 2, but not in large numbers no. We are not saying that no one has ended their life because of the pain, we are saying that fortunately it is not many.
This actually just needs some good old common sense, but we can bring some
facts into it too. First if that had been the case organizations, support groups,
medical journals and governments would have reacted. It would also mean that
the total number of suicides per year would be much higher. We've read statistics from many countries, not just the UK and the US, but let’s have a look
at the numbers in the UK as an example as they are rather in the middle when it comes to suicides per country.
In 2011, 6045 committed suicide in the UK. That gives a ratio of
approximately 12 per 100,000. According to official numbers, the ratio of
people being diagnosed with TN per year is 4 to 5 per 100,000. Would no one react
if such a large number of suicides came from one cause? It becomes even clearer when
we then know that of the 4-5 per 100,000, 80% are women (if we use 4 as the
ratio, 80% is 3.2). If we then compare that to the actual women who committed
suicide in 2011 it shows how impossible that claim is as the ratio for women
are only 5.6 per 100,000. Would no one react in the UK if over half of the women
committed suicide due to TN? Would it not be investigated, talked about and started some inquires? In many countries now war veterans are followed closely just because they have seen they are a risk group. Would they not do the same if it also applied to TN. Of course they would.
The need for real facts –
no more myths
To conclude, the name ”Suicide disease” does not describe any normal
outcome of having the affliction. It has partly a historic component but
is more than anything a descriptive illustration of the intensity and
debilitating pain that trigeminal neuralgia is.
The assumption that having trigeminal neuralgia will lead to suicide is
a myth and has no basis in reality. Statistics don’t exist and the numbers
presented are taken out of thin air.
When dealing with a condition like Trigeminal Neuralgia, it is
imperative that people learn, get educated and diagnosed. We still have a long
way to go before knowledge and awareness are wide-spread.
All awareness is not good
awareness
In the process of raising awareness, understanding and empathy, it’s
extremely important that what is being shared is true. We cannot allow
sensationalism and the need for attention get in the way. We need people to
understand us, to listen to us, to believe us. If they doubt anything, they
will doubt everything. Does anything go as long as it’s in the name of
awareness? No everything does not and should not go. If someone can lie about
something as serious as suicide, what else do they lie about. It will ruin our
credibility.
What can we do to stop the
wrongful information and myth?
Stopping a myth and speculative statements is not easy. But we can try.
We need everybody who is willing to bring about awareness for TN, to do so
without sensationalist postulations and wrongful information. Trigeminal
Neuralgia is bad enough; we do not need to make up figures to make it worse. We have more than enough facts that it is real, that it is very painful and that it is one of the worst. We don't have to make up figures along the way.
We can all start by saying NO to posts, posters, videos, articles etc
that misuse our trust, hope and future. Say NO to those who just play a game
for attention and money. Say NO to those who show no respect for those who is affected
by suicide by their loved ones, the family and friends.
And more importantly, has anyone promoting these false statement
thought about the affect: that their misuse of information might actually lead
to someone taking their life because they see no hope?
Because this is not just about awareness, it’s about so much more; it’s
about children, men and women, fellow human beings that are in a difficult,
vulnerable position. This is not a game, it’s about living breathing people who
suffer, it’s about their families, their friends.
It’s about you, it's about me, it's all of us!
Please note: If you do have suicidal thoughts contact a helpline, your
doctor or someone you can talk to immediately. Do not wait. If you believe a
loved one has suicidal thoughts, act immediately. Most countries have a suicide
or health helpline. Do not hesitate to contact them.
This article is written by End Trigeminal Neuralgia 2014.
Sources:
- J M S
Pearce “Trigeminal neuralgia (Fothergill‘s disease) in the 17th and 18th
centuries“: http://jnnp.bmj.com/content/74/12/1688.full
- Suicide
fact at a glance, National
Center for Injury
Prevention and
Control:http://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/pdf/Suicide_DataSheet-a.pdf
- Suicide
Statistics,
Suicide.org: http://www.suicide.org/suicide-statistics.html
- Coping with
suicidal thoughts, Familydoctor.org:http://familydoctor.org/familydoctor/en/diseases-conditions/depression/symptoms/coping-with-suicidal-thoughts.printerview.all.html
- Suicide
Prevention Guideline,
MedlinePlus:http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/suicide.html
- Articles
from Suicide at
MedlinePlus:http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/suicide.html#cat22http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr61/nvsr61_07.pdf
- Trigeminal
neuralgia information from National health Services
(NHS):http://www.nhs.uk/conditions/Trigeminal-neuralgia/Pages/Introduction.aspx
- Samaritans.org:http://www.samaritans.org/sites/default/files/kcfinder/files/research/Samaritans%20Suicide%20Statistics%20Report%202013.pdf
- Understanding
and Helping the Suicidal Individual (American Association of
Suicidology)http://www.suicidology.org/c/document_library/get_file?folderId=232&name=DLFE-30.pdf
- Suicide and
Suicidal Thoughts(Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and
Research)http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/suicide/basics/definition/CON-20033954?p=1